iPhone: The 800-Pound Gorilla Spawns a 300-Page Bill
It's no surprise, given the new-technology nature of Justine Ezarik's complaint, that she aired her displeasure on YouTube. The Pittsburgh graphic designer posted on the Google-owned Web site a video
that she made while unpacking her first iPhone bill, from service provider AT&T -- a 300-page tome that required its own box.
Other iPhone users swiftly chimed in with their own complaints about the bills, which break out line-by-line every transaction and data transmission made on the iPhone's unlimited data access plans. A user who sends and receives around 20,000 text messages -- as Ezarik claims to have done last month -- would face a brick-like phone bill containing an entry for each message occurred.
So what's going on? Nothing, says AT&T spokesman Mark Siegel -- the company has always detailed customer transactions in this manner.
Still, Adam Zawek thinks more than "business as usual" may be behind the Byzantine bills. "I suspect a messy combination of CRM strategy and billing system limitations," says Zawek says, a spokesman at Boston-based InMobile.org, an online community for wireless executives.
The massive statements, he says, are likely an effort by AT&T to head off expensive calls to its customer-care center by anticipating -- and hopefully answering -- customer questions.
"Fear of customer-care calls is a huge driver of everything because they give someone like AT&T two whammies," Zawek says. "Cost number one: They've upset a customer, who might leave them. Cost number two: The calls themselves are expensive to process."
Zawek speculates that the telecom company is keenly aware that users will be scrutinizing the new device's service levels in these first months after its introduction. The media, too, is anxious to follow the iPhone story.
"AT&T gave Apple a lot of leeway they don't give to other device manufacturers," Zawek says. "But that could come with some risks for their core operation. They're the one company the customer calls with any kind of problem, no matter what it is," he says. "People won't go to Apple. They'll phone AT&T."
Thus the need for exhaustive detail, even if most transactions -- whether for sending a text message, sending a photo, or receiving an email--are simply listed on the bill as "data," as Ezarik points out in her video.
But Mark Evans has a slightly different take on the iPhone's brick-like bills. He's chief executive officer at Quickcomm, a New York company offering telecom-analytics software. A large company would use Quickcomm software to analyze its telephone-bill numbers to find places to wrest savings. Some of Evans's clients get their telephone bills delivered by pallet, he says -- the paperwork is that
While those bills could easily be delivered electronically -- and AT&T does offer that option to iPhone users -- Evans says the itemized paper bills themselves offer an important service. They allow customers to analyze their usage and, if appropriate, switch to a lower-fee plan.
"The information is invaluable," Evans says. "It shows you what you're using."
UPDATE: On Aug. 23, The New York Times reported
that AT&T's wireless business "sent text messages to all its iPhone users to let them know that it will be sending them summarized bills from now on." According to the Times
the text message read, "We are simplifying your paper bill, removing itemized detail. To view all detail go to att.com/mywireless. Still need full paper bill? Call 611." The paper also reported that "[c]ustomers who prefer detailed paper bills will be charged $1.99 a month for each phone line to have these mailed."
The Rise of the Digital Client
Catering to this new breed of always-on customer will require a new approach to CRM.
NetSuite iPhones It In
The on-demand CRM vendor announces full in-browser capabilities for use on the wildly popular new Apple device; CRM on the hip could make Apple the next big mobile business tool.
iPhone: Friend or Foe?
The release of Apple's new iPhone could be a marketer's dream come true.
Feature: Paper Cuts
Most of your customers now say they prefer electronic bills to paper ones. This can be great news -- provided you make the most of the opportunity to strengthen the customer relationship.
Mobility's Killer App?
23 Oct 2007
Nuance Conversations '07: Speech technology will be the key driver of Web innovation, according to a presenter -- primarily through natural language and its use in mobile search.
CRM Vendors Say Hello to the New iPhone
10 Jul 2008
Apple's 3G update to its popular handheld has early support from big names in the industry, but little meat so far.
Bad Billing Will Kill Off Your Biggest Buyers
18 Feb 2009
More than half of telecommunications carriers don't measure customer satisfaction when it comes to enterprise billing.
CRM and the iPhone
01 Mar 2009
Mobile CRM has been around for years, but Apple's handheld device has upended everything. Now vendors are rewriting applications, companies are rethinking the BlackBerry's seeming stranglehold, and users are wondering what's next. The answer may be nothing less than a CRM revolution, and a chance for Apple to enter the enterprise.
Re:Tooling -- Contact Management: Business-Card Shakedown
01 Mar 2009
New applications allowing the electronic exchange of contact information—Web 2.0's answer to traditional cards, or not?
We Reserve the Right to Screw Up Your Service
01 Apr 2009
Service gaffes are part of life, but some of them are just astounding.