Companies Still Miss the Mark on the Complete Customer Experience

Speak with executives from virtually any company or any vendor offering customer service solutions and they'll repeatedly insist that customer service is becoming a key competitive differentiator -- even more so than product and price differentiation. A recent study concludes all this talk right now is just talk, with very few actionable steps being taken to foster this quality customer experience to keep consumers loyal.

Research and consulting firm Strativity Group released telling new statistics from its Customer Experience Management (CEM) global benchmark study, which surveyed 379 executive participants who examined their respective organizations' complete customer experience cycle, including definition, customer-centric organizational alignment, and mechanisms to respond to customer feedback. The results leave Lior Arussy, the firm's president, shocked. "This is a big surprise," he states. "[The results] are a wake up call for organizations."

According to the study, 80 percent of the executives surveyed "strongly agree that customer strategies are more important to companies' success than ever before." However, Arussy insists that additional study results show companies are not following through on what they believe to be important.

Other statistics from the CEM study include:

  • 43.9 percent of respondents believe their companies deserve their customers' loyalty;
  • 42.6 percent believe their companies' products and services are not worth the price they charge;
  • 56 percent of respondents say their companies have differentiated and beneficial products and services;
  • 34.8 percent indicate that their company has a dedicated CEM role;
  • 27.2 percent say the definition of the customer experience is "well-defined and communicated" in their companies;
  • 28.8 percent of respondents indicate their employees have the tools and authority to solve customer problems; and
  • 23.9 percent agree that their employees are "well-versed in how to delight customers."

The fact that 56 percent of respondents believe their respective companies differentiate on their products and services, while only 34.8 percent indicate their company has a dedicated CEM role leads to a lingering problem, according to Arussy. "Organizations are still operating on a product centricity model," he says. "[Companies are] trying to put nice packaging on a value proposition that has yet to fully address the complete customer problem. Companies need to make the leap toward complete customer centricity and redefine the problem solely from the perspective of the customer instead of...what they do and their skill set."

To illustrate this point, Arussy gives the example of what Apple did with the iPod. He explains that there were other MP3 players on the market, and if the software giant decided to define the customer problem from its skill set, "it would say 'the world needs another iPod,'" he recalls. However, the problem didn't loom solely around product differentiation. "In reality, there were no available legal digital music sites, and there were no portals in which they could download in a seamless way," he says. "The whole digital music user experience was rather difficult." Apple attacked the issue by creating iTunes, which offers legal music downloads and integration with a digital music collection and the iPod. Just like Apple, Arussy says companies need to define core competence and look at things from the customer's perspective in order to determine "what's holding them back from enjoying [products and services] all the way."

While Arussy says all the statistics are alarming, he notes the 28.8 percent of respondents claiming their employees have the tools and authority to solve customer problems is very disappointing. "That's an extremely low number," he insists. "We're talking about 72 percent of employees in customer service and sales showing up to the customer with nothing more than a smile on their face."

While it seems as though companies are alone in their customer experience failures, Arussy maintains vendors providing customer service solutions should also be held accountable. He argues companies are rushing to buy tools from these vendors without having any strategy or operational context to use the tools optimally. "There's a great irresponsibility that's happening in the CRM industry, selling tools out there and we know that [companies] don't know what to do with them in order to fulfill whatever promise there was," he laments. "That's why we end up with the same exact thing as when we started, and [this study] is a wake-up call to all the vendors as well. I think technology vendors should assume greater responsibility in helping organizations develop the strategies and operational context necessary."

Arussy says the greatest hope with the results of this study is that everyone will "understand that business as usual is not getting us anywhere." It's going to take, he argues, a hard look at the complete journey of the customer experience. "It's not just anecdotal and not just customer service," he concludes. "We need to go back to the core of what we are selling to customers, and is it worth the money."

Related articles:

Feature: The Excellence Myth
In an exclusive excerpt from his new book Excellence Every Day, industry thought leader Lior Arussy examines the truth -- and crippling fictions -- behind the value of customer experience.

Varolii's New Collections Products Get Collected
Looking to guide companies through a gloomy economy, the on-demand communications provider's newest offerings are prepackaged -- and predictive.

Tealeaf Soaks Up Online Customer Experience
The provider of customer experience applications for e-commerce companies adds new capabilities to its front and back ends.

Customer Confidence Fizzles to Lowest Level in Decades
Retailers beware: Survey blames inflation, unemployment, and smaller income gains for buyer burnout.

The Tipping Point: Serving Up Customer Delight
Embracing customer centricity isn't the same as delivering it.

Reality Check: The Longitude of Experience
Reconsidering the life cycle of customer interaction.

Secret of My Success: Hatching a Customer-Connection Plan
Egg, the British online bank, knows what its customers are thinking all the time, thanks to surveys conducted by Confirmit.

Want Customer Loyalty? Improve Customer Experience First.
Recent reports from Forrester find an increasing emphasis on customer experience -- and a payoff in terms of customer retention.

Kana and IBM Team Up for New Customer Experience Solutions
Expanding an existing partnership, the companies are expecting services-oriented architecture to help foster "seamless" customer-service integration.

Customer Satisfaction Is Just the Beginning
According to statistics from a newly published study, organizations are realizing that "customer satisfaction" means far more than just "happy customers."

9 Essential Strategies to Improve Customer Experience
SAP CRM 2008: As advertising budgets shift to online efforts, customer care is where the money is.

Viewpoint: The Importance of Customer Experience in a Downturn
Beware the "cut prices" first line of defense.

Viewpoint: Invest in the Online Customer Experience
The rewards are worth reaping.

Viewpoint: Want Superior Customer Experience in Your Contact Center?
Start with superior agent experience.

Viewpoint: It's All About the Customer Experience
Organizations must understand their customers and adapt to their behavior.

Viewpoint: Four Components of the Successful Customer Experience
It's about more than fulfilling a transaction.

CRM Covers
for qualified subscribers
Subscribe Now Current Issue Past Issues

Related Articles

Wake Up! The New Customer Refuses to be Bored

destinationCRM 2008: Keynote addresses today's customer demands and what companies can do to keep them coming back.

Conflict Cripples the Customer Experience

destinationCRM 2008: The push to truly provide a differentiated service experience must take into account the consumer's ecosystem—not the companies'.

Customer Emotion Management?

destinationCRM 2008: To build customer loyalty, make experiences memorable.

Right Message, Right Channel, Right Time

Varolii looks to go three-for-three with its latest array of automated communication applications.

Confirmit Sets Its Sights on the Horizon

The enterprise feedback management vendor broadens its multichannel reach and releases a new on-demand platform.

Is Customer Experience Experiencing Critical Mass?

100 percent of companies surveyed by Aberdeen Group report either having customer experience management in place or planning on having it within 30 months.

The Unseen Force Behind Customer Experience

destinationCRM 2008: The missing link in providing quality service is an effective contact center manager.

Service Providers Can't Define the Customer Experience

In a growing trend across all verticals, the latest Yankee Group study finds 50 percent of service providers cannot explain what the customer experience should be.

CRM Versus CEM

Ventana Research's latest benchmark study lays out the difference between the two, and suggests why the "E" might have more future success than the "R."

Buyer's Guide Companies Mentioned