• October 23, 2009
  • By Jessica Tsai, Assistant Editor, CRM magazine

They've Got Your Number, Sort of

At a conference that, in the name alone, suggests the expanse -- or at least the potential for a high degree of impact -- of predictive analytics, Stephen Baker, senior writer of BusinessWeek, opted to talk less about the opportunities the technology. Instead, he would focus on its pitfalls, or "what the world doesn't want from predictive analytics." (BusinessWeek will reportedly be renamed Bloomberg BusinessWeek since its acquisition by the financial news and information company).

Baker recalled the first time he was edited by a machine. Without much thought beyond journalist creativity, he had begun one of his blogposts with a series of questions. An hour after he had eventually published the piece, he received a call from one of BusinessWeek's search engine optimization (SEO) experts requesting that Baker change his introduction. "You never start with questions," Baker said, imitating the SEO expert, "the computer can't understand questions. So I had to rewrite the thing for the computer."

"What we learned to do over the decades is appeal to people with humor, irony," he said. These nuances of the human language like sarcasm aren't meant to be captured by machines, and yet, by making the language clear to the computer, Baker admitted that it's actually enabling us to communicate with a broader audience.

When Baker wrote The Numerati he had the generalist in mind, the person who perhaps didn't know what analytics was, let alone understand analytics. "This isn't a book about how do to it," he told the audience, "This is a book for everyone that doesn't have a clue...who think they're being analyzed by people they don't know." Unfotunately, he lamented, the greatest readership came from those in the field seeking affirmation.

People are scared of predictive analytics, a result largely of which is mere hearsay. Results from machine learning, Baker said, is "extremely imprecise." However, the industry is attempting to build a business case around this "crude understanding" of the ‘individual," even if, ultimately, the interpretation is wrong. The problem with this approach, he said, is that because it's being passed as a truth-rather than a "vague approximation," people are getting scared. Actually being able to model humans, he said, is still in its very early stages.

Large companies like IBM have derived optimization strategies that look at employees as machine parts-how to be more efficient at a given task-and financial portfolios-how much is a worker worth and what is the need and predicted output 10 years from now. Being able to predict these outcomes, Baker said, despite its imprecision, can at times yield a merely one to two percent improvement in productivity, but can translate into a substantial cost savings for companies the size of IBM. However, if this predictive capability is perceived as a truth in human optimization, "it freaks people out," he said.

He admitted, however, that he's just as guilty for cashing in on the "miracle of analytics." The marketing for his book overplayed the Big Brother effect, to which Baker, at the dismay of his editor, had to respond, "They don't know everything about you. You're in a bucket, just a small component." So long as the industry exaggerates the capabilities of predictive analytics, he said, the harsher the backlash.

Portfolio.com writer Roger Lowenstein said, not so approvingly, that Baker is the cheerleader of "the Numerati," those who will "model your behavior and ferret you out"-whether you're a "a crook or a would-be terrorist," or "a potential Tide buyer or an undecided voter in a swing state."

Baker admitted he make have skirted the issues of privacy in his book, or at least not given it the attention readers may have wanted. His own reasons include a disinterest in the issue, as well as his reluctance to get entangled with lawyers. Even so, he knows that the privacy-or rather, the threat of danger-sells. "The British are changing the title of my book to, They've Got Your Number." Consumers, however, are misinformed as a result of this fear tactic. "They think, "I don't want them to know that about me,'" Baker said, laughing in near disbelief as he conveyed the notion that people actually believe the Numerati are sitting around their computers watching individual purchasing behaviors and thinking, "Oh, it's funny that the just bought that."

"When we became industrialized...intelligence and analytics went into manufacturing and distribution--that's when we got slaughtered," he said. People weren't recognized understood-they were treated as herds divided into large demographic categories (urban, suburban, white, black, young old). "We've associated ant-like status with privacy," he said. With more data in the systems, however, companies are becoming knowledgeable again. Those who can earn the consumer's trust by increasing transparency and making the rules of privacy-or what Baker called the "privacy payoff"-extremely clear will get the business.

News relevant to the customer relationship management industry is posted several times a day on destinationCRM.com, in addition to the news section Insight that appears every month in the pages of CRM magazine. You may leave a public comment regarding this article by clicking on "Comments" at the top; to contact the editors, please email editor@destinationCRM.com.

CRM Covers
for qualified subscribers
Subscribe Now Current Issue Past Issues

Related Articles

Adobe to Acquire Omniture

Pundits say the $1.8 billion deal — uniting a provider of development platforms with arguably the predominant player in Web analytics — has the potential to finally make measurement a powerful aspect of interactive media.

Re:Tooling -- Predictive Analytics: Keeping a Step Ahead

To cope with the recession, more organizations are looking to predictive analytics for answers.

Omniture Tops Forrester Wave in Web Analytics

Innovation isn't slowing down as vendors meet the increasing demand to merge online and offline data.

Webtrends Looks to Reclaim Position in Web Analytics Market

In what the company calls its biggest launch ever, Webtrends unveils Analytics 9 and acquires Widemile.

SPSS Collects, Collaborates, and Deploys — All in the Name of Analytics

With new versions of PASW Data Collection and PASW Collaboration and Deployment Services, SPSS helps analysts and business users alike manage the voice of the customer.

"Second-Generation Analytics" with Quantivo's Omniture Adapter

Using data from Omniture SiteCatalyst, Quantivo aims to perform deeper analytics, faster.

Predictive Analytics Can Pinpoint Profitable Customers

Customer retention is one thing. Identifying the right ones to retain is another.

The Power of Foresight: Top Companies Use Predictive Analytics

Better customer information leads to higher retention rates.

Omniture Extends Web Analytics to Mobile

With Web-enabled mobile devices on the rise, the company's mobile analytics will enhance its latest SiteCatalyst release.

Building on BI with Predictive Analytics

Information Builders Summit '08: Information Builders strengthens its WebFOCUS platform, delivering on cost-effectiveness and demands for analytics.

WebTrends Launches Dynamic Search

The company's new multivariant testing app automatically uses advertising resources where they're the most effective; one analyst says the paid search market is open for WebTrends.

Analytics Proponents Are Often All Alone

SPSS Directions '07: Panelists advocating statistical solutions at the company's North American conference seem to be mavericks of the business industry.